Thursday, 6 January 2011

To kill or not to kill

I am against the death penalty and no, it has nothing to do with leniency or mercy. Throughout history it has been assumed that death is the severest punishment that could be handed down to a criminal but I want to present another perspective. I’m hoping to change people’s opinion on executing someone even if he is guilty of murder. I am not in any way compassionate towards people who never felt the same when they snuffed another’s life out. It’s that I feel death is too easy a way out for the perpetrator of the crime and in some cases death is exactly what the perpetrator wants. I agree that an ‘eye for an eye’ and ‘a tooth for a tooth’ sounds like the most logical thing to do and if it was my family that was harmed I too would probably cry for blood but for now I’m not overcome with emotion and therefore can think with a clear mind. So here is my proposition.

Take the case of Ajmal Amir Kasab, the only terrorist who was captured alive during the Mumbai terror attacks. That little prick along with his comrades wrecked havoc on a prosperous city in the name of an illogical human concept called religion. Thanks to texts in the sacred books, it was possible for a bunch of anti-India, anti-‘anything but their religion’, anti-progress guys from across the border to brainwash Kasab and his mates, and to make them embark on what they thought would get them on a fast track to their god. We all know what then happened and now almost the whole of India is waiting to see him hang but I think that would be the most stupid thing to do. He came here prepared to die and to become a hero in the eyes of his fellow deluded nuts. Killing him will only get him what he wants and strengthen the position of all those who were instrumental in executing the terror plan.

I say keep the perpetrator alive for the rest of his natural life but keep him confined and isolated. Denying a man contact with a fellow human being will eventually drive him insane and he’ll beg to be killed. Every moment of his waking life he should remember why he has been incarcerated and as in the case of Kasab it will deny him his dream. He was eager to die and go indulge in his orgy as had been promised to him by his religious leaders. Seventy Two doe eyed virgins are supposedly waiting to f*** him till eternity. He is a healthy young guy and that would mean he should be around for at the least another forty years. Forty years of deprivation will force him to reflect on all the things he did and drive him nuts. What could be a better deterrent to prospective terrorists than the thought of having to jerk off till the lines on their hands wear out?


ArunRamasamy said...

I completely understand n partly agree to your way of punishment.... the only problem in your proposition is our Law.... n the officially executing it.... if the prisoner is rich he gets a special treatment.... when there is no corruption then wat u say can definitely be implemented... would love to discuss more abt this but got to run may be some other time..... Keep up ur good Work..... Have a Great Day.... :-)

Paddy said...

Hi Adithya,
I completely agree with you. When Kasab gets all the time to reflect without human contact, he may even discard religion, which is a bunch of BS put together by various ignorant and / or conniving men over a long period of time.

Kasab may come to realize that Nature, animals including homo-sapiens, and plants are the only game in town and hence morality really should be judged on how much good we do to the rest of the society.

Unfortunately in Kasab's world morality is entirely judged by his / her relationship with the supernatural and hence he does not mind hurting the nature and human beings around him.

Only if we are allowed to seek the truth, such hatred for fellow human beings will diminish.
But, Relision prevents us from seeking the truth. Following tradition is seen as being moral. If I do sandiyavandanam twice a day, I am moral even though my Sandiyavandanam might delay my arrival at work by 10 minutes. I say, your practicing sandiyavandanam is immoral behaviour because you have not given your best by arriving at work late by 10 minutes. You have corrupted this world and have contributed to the decay in productivity by arriving to work late.
Any way I might have digressed a bit.
Enjoyed reading your blog.
Keep up the good work.

Sagoki said...

A nice article..,even I oppose Death Penalty and your article will help me in a great way to substantiate my arguements against my friends.

Sagoki said...

I am also against Death penalty....Your article is very well written and it will help me to substantiate my views in this regard

My medley said...

Hey Adithya....A very nice article...couldn't agree with u more... keeping any human confined and isolated is a far more cruel punishment,and will force him to reflect on all his actions....but on the other hand if he's given death,he's gonna be a hero and million such kasab's will be born.Enjoyed reading your blog....

Adithya said...

Glad to see you all comment here and concur. Thanks for the time you have all taken. Cheers!